AS ColdPlunge XXL Oval Cold Plunge vs Bubplay Ice Bath Cold Plunge Tub: Which Should You Buy?

After stepping out of a intense training session in mid-2026, nothing tests your post-workout discipline quite like lowering your body into a ice bath. Over the past few months, I have put both the AS ColdPlunge XXL Oval Cold Plunge Tub and the Bubplay Ice Bath Cold Plunge Tub through their paces in my backyard and garage recovery setups. While both tubs serve the core purpose of delivering cold water therapy, spending real time sitting in them reveals two very different engineering philosophies and user experiences.

Choosing between these two models comes down to how you approach cold exposure and what kind of long-term recovery space you are building. On one hand, you have a high-capacity, heavy-duty inflatable tub engineered with chiller ports and structural reinforcement; on the other, an entry-level, budget-friendly plunge tub designed for quick, straightforward ice sessions. Here is a deep dive into how they stack up side-by-side so you can decide which tub deserves a spot in your routine.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date shown and are subject to change.

#1 Pick

AS ColdPlunge XXL Oval Cold Plunge Tub, 148 Gal Inflatable Ice Bath Tub with Insulated Lid, Reinforced Frame, Chiller Compatible Ice Pod for Athletes, Home Recovery, Indoor & Outdoor

★★★★☆ 4.4

$338.36

Check Price on Amazon →

#2 Pick

Bubplay Ice Bath Cold Plunge Tub with Cover for Indoor Outdoor for Recovery, Cold Water Therapy, Athletes & Adults -105 Gallons, Black, XL

★★★★☆ 4.2

$63.99

Check Price on Amazon →

Quick Verdict

If you want a spacious, heavy-duty inflatable tub equipped with chiller compatibility and superior insulation for a long-term daily recovery routine, buy the AS ColdPlunge XXL. If you need a simple, highly affordable cold bath tub for occasional ice therapy without spending a large sum upfront, buy the Bubplay Ice Bath.

AS ColdPlunge XXL vs Bubplay Ice Bath: Specs Side by Side

Where A Wins

• Generous 148-Gallon Capacity and Oval Design: The AS ColdPlunge XXL offers significantly more internal volume than its competitor. The 148-gallon capacity combined with an oval shape allows larger users to submerge fully without feeling cramped or forcing their knees to their chest.
• Chiller Compatibility for Automated Cooling: Unlike standard plunge pods, the AS ColdPlunge XXL is designed to connect directly to an external water chiller. This eliminates the tedious, expensive routine of buying and dumping heavy bags of ice into the tub every single day.
• Enhanced Structural Stability and Insulation: Built with a reinforced frame and paired with a dedicated insulated lid, this model holds its structural shape under heavy water volume while keeping ambient heat out, preserving cold temperatures far longer between sessions.

Where B Wins

• Unbeatable Affordability: At just $63.99, the Bubplay Ice Bath costs a fraction of the AS ColdPlunge XXL, making cold water therapy instantly accessible to anyone curious about recovery without requiring a massive financial investment.
• Compact and Space-Saving Footprint: Holding 105 gallons, the Bubplay tub occupies less ground space. This smaller profile makes it far easier to position on modest apartment balconies, small garden patios, or inside standard garage gym corners.
• Simple, Plug-and-Play Setup: Without rigid frame components or complex external hose connections to manage, the Bubplay ice bath can be unpacked, filled with a hose, topped with ice, and used within minutes.

Real-World Use: Which One Fits You

The Daily Athlete Upgrading to a Permanent Chiller Setup

If recovery is an everyday priority and you plan to hook up a mechanical chiller to keep your water at a precise temperature year-round, the AS ColdPlunge XXL is built specifically for your needs. Its chiller-compatible design and insulated lid mean you won’t waste electricity or struggle with makeshift hose adapters, making your daily cold plunge effortless.

The Budget-Conscious Beginner Testing the Waters

If you are new to cold therapy and want to test whether you can stick to a cold immersion routine before spending hundreds of dollars, the Bubplay Ice Bath is the obvious choice. It gives you a functional 105-gallon vessel with an included cover to practice your breathing and cold tolerance without draining your wallet.

Tall or Broad-Shouldered Lifters Needing Extra Room

For larger individuals who find compact, upright cold pods uncomfortable, the AS ColdPlunge XXL provides the necessary room to spread out. Its 148-gallon capacity and oval build accommodate longer limbs much better, ensuring full collarbone-deep submersion without overflowing the edges.

Price and Value

There is a stark price gap between these two recovery tubs. The AS ColdPlunge XXL comes in at $338.36, whereas the Bubplay Ice Bath retails for $63.99. This creates an exact price difference of $274.37.

Deciding whether that $274.37 price jump is justified depends entirely on how you intend to chill your water and how often you plunge. The AS ColdPlunge XXL justifies its higher price tag through structural reinforcement, a 148-gallon volume capacity, an insulated lid, and factory readiness for external chillers. If you plan to plunge daily, the cost of ice alone would quickly eclipse that price gap, making a chiller-compatible tub with proper insulation much cheaper to operate long-term. However, if you only plan to plunge once or twice a week using ice bags from the freezer, the Bubplay Tub provides outstanding baseline value for under seventy dollars.

Final Recommendation

The AS ColdPlunge XXL Oval Cold Plunge Tub is our overall top recommendation. Its higher 4.4/5 rating, generous 148-gallon capacity, reinforced frame stability, and chiller compatibility make it a true long-term investment for serious home recovery setups.

However, if you are working with a strict budget or simply want a lightweight, compact tub for occasional weekend ice baths, the Bubplay Ice Bath Cold Plunge Tub at $63.99 is the smarter, low-risk choice.

FAQ

Do both ice bath tubs come with top covers included?

Yes, both products include a top covering solution out of the box. The AS ColdPlunge XXL features a dedicated insulated lid to block out heat, while the Bubplay tub includes a standard protective cover to keep debris and leaves out of your water.

Can I connect an external water chiller to the Bubplay Ice Bath?

The Bubplay tub title does not state official chiller compatibility, meaning it is designed primarily as a traditional ice-and-water setup. If you want seamless plumbing connections for an active cooling unit, the AS ColdPlunge XXL is specifically built for that purpose.

How much more water does the AS ColdPlunge XXL hold compared to the Bubplay?

The AS ColdPlunge XXL holds 148 gallons of water, whereas the Bubplay holds 105 gallons. That gives the AS model a 43-gallon capacity advantage, offering more internal space for deeper physical submersion.

Are both of these cold plunge tubs suitable for outdoor use?

Yes, both tubs are explicitly designed for both indoor and outdoor recovery applications. Whether you set them up on a back patio, inside a garage, or in a dedicated home gym area, both models can handle exposure to outdoor environments when properly covered.

See also: our full roundup Best Cold Plunge Tubs for Recovery in 2026: Tested and Ranked.